Where would you like to stay?
Select number of bedrooms
Add dates

City Guides


Jan 28, 2016

Best Pizza in Manhattan: Our Top 4 Picks in Midtown NYC

Looking for the best pizza in Manhattan? While New York City has no shortage of delicious pizza spots, it isn’t always east to make the trek from borough to borough. However, if you find yourself in Midtown Manhattan, you can’t go wrong with these four places to pick up a slice or a whole pie:

Don Antonio By Starita

One Yelp reviewer claims their Margherita pizza is the “best [they’ve] ever had outside of Italy.” We can’t argue with that—Don Antonio’s pizza keeps us coming back. There’s usually a short wait at this Midtown Manhattan pizza place—but the fresh flavors and perfect crust are worth it. Grab a friend or date, maybe indulge in a bottle of wine and enjoy the all-around excellent dining experience at Don Antonio.

309 West 50th Street, New York

La Tarte Flambee

This fabulous French bar and restaurant in Midtown East is a must visit among all options available for a pizza Midtown NYC. Perfect for a romantic evening or small get-together with friends, La Tarte Flambee’s specialty is just that—tarte flambees. If you’re unfamiliar with this delectable French dish, their website states: “If a pizza and a crepe had a baby, it would be a tarte flambee!” So maybe it’s not pizza as we know it, but you won’t regret biting into their airy flatbread with bacon, onions and gruyere cheese. Check out the rest of La Tarte Flambee’s menu.

153 East 33rd Street, New York

B Side Pizza & Wine Bar

This Hell’s Kitchen joint is another wonderful option for pizza in Midtown NYC. The quality and service are great and the relaxed atmosphere is perfect for an after work get-together or casual date.  Try B Side’s Oscar the Grouch pizza which includes spinach, black kale, garlic and mozzarella fonduta or go for the Meat Packing pizza which features tomato, pancetta, bacon, sausage and more tasty toppings. Treat yourself to their Classic Tiramisu for dessert.

370 West 51st Street, New York

Vezzo Thin Crust Pizza

If you’re a fan of thin crust pizza, look no further than Vezzo. Favorites include Shroomtown which includes marinara sauce, cheese, portobello, shitake and button mushrooms, and white truffle oil and the Bacon Cheese Burger pizza—marinara sauce, cheese, ground beef, bacon, etc. If you’re in the mood for pasta, try the Rigatoni in Bolognese Sauce or the Salmon Carbonara.

178 Lexington Avenue

Discover More Local Favorites in Manhattan!

Explore our blog and find out where you can get the best coffee, brunch or happy hour during your extended stay in NYC!

Furnished Quarters is the premier supplier of short-term housing and an accredited LGBTQ+ diverse, privately owned and operated company.

© 2024 Furnished Quarters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.